Will you be a microISV casualty?


When discussing success rates for new business startups, most people are quick to quote the statistic that 95% of new businesses will fail within X (1, 3, or 5 seem to be most common) number of years. If this is true, then the failure of microISV businesses will be no different. What’s interesting is why the majority of microISV companies fail.

The main reason that the majority of the companies with completed products fail is due to the lack of marketing. This would seem to be obvious because most microISV businesses are created by programmers who don’t have experience or, in a lot of cases, the desire to do the marketing that is necessary to make their product a success. My observation is that there are far more microISV companies that fail before they even get to this stage though.

The simple explanation is that most microISVs will fail because they will never complete their product. But why is this the case? Even though the common way of thinking is to start your microISV while holding down a day job, which is the method of minimal risk, most people fail because they actually fear the risk of success. Once someone starts down the path of creating a project with the grand idea of leaving their crappy job behind they will inevitably end up having to face the idea of not having a steady paycheck, paying self employment taxes, and, in the U.S., paying for health insurance entirely out of your own pocket. With these thoughts the spiral begins.

Unfortunately, we have become a world of comfort. It is all to easy to go to school, get a job, work up, around, and through the corporate world and continue to draw a steady paycheck. Faced with the comfort of a steady job, the decision to risk success on your own actually becomes a daunting thought to many. At this point, the easiest thing to do is quit. It requires no change since you have a steady, stable paycheck. You won’t have the hassle of working on your project at night and on the weekends. And think of all the time you won’t have to spend supporting your customers. Life will go back to being comfortable…and disappointing.

Always remember why you started your project in the first place. The goals you set originally were what you thought would provide you with an improved lifestyle. The lifestyle and level of comfort that can be attained by selling something you created yourself can be far more satisfactory even if you never make as much money as you did in your corporate job, so don’t become a microISV casualty before you even get started.

6 Responses to “Will you be a microISV casualty?”

  1. Patrick Paulin Says:

    I agree entirely, and I’d make a suggestion for how to get around these issues. If you’d like to start a microISV in the future, consider working as an independent consultant for a few years.

    Chances are you’ll be doing the same work you do now, but you’ll be getting experience with business accounting, unemployment insurance, health insurance, and business tax returns. You’ll learn how to incorporate a business and get used to having a business bank account. The best part is you get to learn all of this in relative safety. You can always hop back into full-time employment if you choose.

    When you’re ready to start your microISV, much of the infrastructure will already be in place, and you won’t feel as overwhelmed by the transition.

  2. Tim Weiler Says:

    I think you hit the nail on the head, Brian. Your observations ring true based on the many posts and responses I have read on the various microISV forums available on the web.

    BUT, some microISVers do hold on long enough to finish their first product, market it, support it, and eventually start a stable full-time business.

    The question is, what gives them that strength?

    I would like to think that the microISV community is starting to play a role here. It definitely is for me. The large number of positive responses to a post I placed on Joel On Software (http://discuss.joelonsoftware.com/default.asp?joel.3.244123.26) questioning the amount of effort I have put into my product is a great example of the kind of boost that the community can provide.

  3. Tony Says:

    I know this isn’t the main thrust of your article, but those “failure” statistics are misleading. The SBA considers any business that is no longer in existence after 5 years as having failed. However, this doesn’t take into account businesses that have been acquired, probably the ultimate liquidity event for a micro-ISV. It also doesn’t take into account one-shot businesses (e.g. film production companies formed specificially to produce a single film) and so on.

  4. Brian Plexico Says:

    Tony,
    I agree completely, but I didn’t want to get sidetracked with the main point of the post.

  5. Ian Ringrose Says:

    What is failing?
    ================

    If I write some software get good skills doing so, can use the software as an example of my work. Therefore I get a great job. Have I failed if I then close down my microISV?

    www.ringrose.name

  6. Ian Says:

    >Have I failed if I then close down my microISV?

    Yes. Unless your true goal was to just get experience.

    I like to look at the upside too, but lets not kid ourselves with second place rhetoric.

Will you be a microISV casualty?


When discussing success rates for new business startups, most people are quick to quote the statistic that 95% of new businesses will fail within X (1, 3, or 5 seem to be most common) number of years. If this is true, then the failure of microISV businesses will be no different. What’s interesting is why the majority of microISV companies fail.

The main reason that the majority of the companies with completed products fail is due to the lack of marketing. This would seem to be obvious because most microISV businesses are created by programmers who don’t have experience or, in a lot of cases, the desire to do the marketing that is necessary to make their product a success. My observation is that there are far more microISV companies that fail before they even get to this stage though.

The simple explanation is that most microISVs will fail because they will never complete their product. But why is this the case? Even though the common way of thinking is to start your microISV while holding down a day job, which is the method of minimal risk, most people fail because they actually fear the risk of success. Once someone starts down the path of creating a project with the grand idea of leaving their crappy job behind they will inevitably end up having to face the idea of not having a steady paycheck, paying self employment taxes, and, in the U.S., paying for health insurance entirely out of your own pocket. With these thoughts the spiral begins.

Unfortunately, we have become a world of comfort. It is all to easy to go to school, get a job, work up, around, and through the corporate world and continue to draw a steady paycheck. Faced with the comfort of a steady job, the decision to risk success on your own actually becomes a daunting thought to many. At this point, the easiest thing to do is quit. It requires no change since you have a steady, stable paycheck. You won’t have the hassle of working on your project at night and on the weekends. And think of all the time you won’t have to spend supporting your customers. Life will go back to being comfortable…and disappointing.

Always remember why you started your project in the first place. The goals you set originally were what you thought would provide you with an improved lifestyle. The lifestyle and level of comfort that can be attained by selling something you created yourself can be far more satisfactory even if you never make as much money as you did in your corporate job, so don’t become a microISV casualty before you even get started.

6 Responses to “Will you be a microISV casualty?”

  1. Patrick Paulin Says:

    I agree entirely, and I’d make a suggestion for how to get around these issues. If you’d like to start a microISV in the future, consider working as an independent consultant for a few years.

    Chances are you’ll be doing the same work you do now, but you’ll be getting experience with business accounting, unemployment insurance, health insurance, and business tax returns. You’ll learn how to incorporate a business and get used to having a business bank account. The best part is you get to learn all of this in relative safety. You can always hop back into full-time employment if you choose.

    When you’re ready to start your microISV, much of the infrastructure will already be in place, and you won’t feel as overwhelmed by the transition.

  2. Tim Weiler Says:

    I think you hit the nail on the head, Brian. Your observations ring true based on the many posts and responses I have read on the various microISV forums available on the web.

    BUT, some microISVers do hold on long enough to finish their first product, market it, support it, and eventually start a stable full-time business.

    The question is, what gives them that strength?

    I would like to think that the microISV community is starting to play a role here. It definitely is for me. The large number of positive responses to a post I placed on Joel On Software (http://discuss.joelonsoftware.com/default.asp?joel.3.244123.26) questioning the amount of effort I have put into my product is a great example of the kind of boost that the community can provide.

  3. Tony Says:

    I know this isn’t the main thrust of your article, but those “failure” statistics are misleading. The SBA considers any business that is no longer in existence after 5 years as having failed. However, this doesn’t take into account businesses that have been acquired, probably the ultimate liquidity event for a micro-ISV. It also doesn’t take into account one-shot businesses (e.g. film production companies formed specificially to produce a single film) and so on.

  4. Brian Plexico Says:

    Tony,
    I agree completely, but I didn’t want to get sidetracked with the main point of the post.

  5. Ian Ringrose Says:

    What is failing?
    ================

    If I write some software get good skills doing so, can use the software as an example of my work. Therefore I get a great job. Have I failed if I then close down my microISV?

    www.ringrose.name

  6. Ian Says:

    >Have I failed if I then close down my microISV?

    Yes. Unless your true goal was to just get experience.

    I like to look at the upside too, but lets not kid ourselves with second place rhetoric.

© 2004-2006 microISV.com